It’s all in the title, really.
I’m writing this as an update and because I can’t stop thinking about it and because I’m in an incredibly strange place right now of actually obtaining the goal I’ve been fantasising about for a long time.
And I’m writing it because when I was researching agents, and then when I was on submission to editors, I was sad and desperate enough to search the net for any kind of clue on how other writers have dealt with this process. How long it took them to get picked up. If they were rejected, and how long that took. Honesty about what they thought they did wrong and what they did right.
From the day I sent out an email query to an agent, to the day that agent and I said yes to a book deal offer, took just under two months.
I am lucky. Lucky lucky lucky. Luckity luck. Ad infinitum.
But I'm not rare in that - not even slightly - and I'm sure many people have had shorter paths than me. When an agent or an editor likes something, they move fast. Like Roadrunner fast. It’s being lucky enough to find that specific agent AND editor who like your book enough to move that fast that’s the magic, unknowable formula.
So below is my path, so far, to being published. I hope it helps, if you’re reading it for that kind of reason. But know that things work very differently for everyone; some of the most successful writers in the world have a long, rocky road. Some writers get a deal in a snap, then disappear. Sorry. It’s a shitty, unhelpful, throwaway thing to say, but it’s also true…
My first book did not get an agent or a publisher.
But then again, I didn’t make as much effort as I should have and also stumbled over the requisite rookie errors…
My first book is slightly shit, to say the least. It has some good bits. There’s potential there, I think; somewhere underneath all the pretentiousness and the over-ambition, there’s a writer in there trying to get out. Sometimes I feel an urge to pull it out and have a look to see if it’s salvageable. It might well be.
I started to write that book when I was about eighteen. A combination of no particular urgency on it and laziness caused me to finish it when I was about 24, 25; but I started putting out feelers way before I had finished it. Rookie error number 1.
Working as a bookseller meant that I got to meet agents, editors and writers at events – best part of the job, hands down. At one of these evenings, I met a very well known editor, now turned agent, who got talking to me in that polite fashion you do at these things, and he just came out with it: “So, are you a writer?”
Nonplussed, I asked him why he would say that.
“A lot of people in the industry are,” was his reply. I suspect what he meant was that I had a slight whiff of ingratiation about my person.
I said yes, I was, and managed to persuade him to let me email him in the near future to ask for advice. He was very lovely to me when he didn’t have to be (knowing shit all about whether I could actually write or not) and answered my emails with patience and advice. He passed my sample chapters onto an editor at Tor, who was also very lovely when she had no call to be and told me that she thought there was some extremely good writing in there but that it wasn’t different enough from other books on their list to consider taking on. She strongly recommended I find an agent, and gave me two agencies that I should submit to.
I duly did, without even really doing any proper research on query letters first. Rookie error number 2. One ‘form rejected’ me (polite rejection without any reasons why, which I think means it got as far as one of their slush pile readers and no further) – the other never replied.
Oh, I thought.
Undiscouraged, I continued to write when I wanted to, rather than exercising any kind of regular determination. Life got in the way – I moved jobs, twice; moved cities, and spent 10 months unemployed, my waking moments devoted to applying for jobs and attending interviews. And, when I wanted to hide from the world for a while, writing.
Book 2 started to surface – the one that eventually became Fearsome Dreamer. Oh, and I went through a lot of titles before I came up with that one – some hilariously bad, some just bland. But that’s for a whole other post.
Right, I thought. You’re not going to make the same mistakes you did with the first one, you twit. You will research. You will wait. And then wait some more. You will finish the damn thing and then you will revise the damn thing until it is really, actually finished.
And THEN you will query.
I wanted to submit it to an unpublished writer competition that had just surfaced on my radar. Trouble was, the deadline was in just under two months, and I had only several chapters under my belt. Fuck it, I thought. What do I have to lose?
And then I discovered a wonderful, magical thing.
When I have a deadline, I actually write every day, like you're apparently supposed to do. I completed a first draft of the whole novel in 7 weeks, at the same time as working full time at an extremely busy job; in time for the competition deadline. I RULE, I thought. I RULE UTTERLY AND WILL CONQUER THE WRITTEN WORD.
Feeling relieved and pleased with myself, I sent off my submission.
Rookie error number 3. I sent off… my first draft.
I hadn’t even revised the damn thing.
Needless to say, I didn’t win :)
Working in publishing didn’t give me a giant advantage in landing an agent or a publisher – at least from my perspective!
- I work in marketing – we don’t get to meet agents that often. I personally knew precisely none.
- Someone in editorial would understand a hell of a lot better than me on how to query – they see submissions all the time. I researched how to query online.
- I obviously do have friends who are also editors, but I don’t, I repeat, don’t like to talk about my writing at work. I get severe embarrassment pangs mixing those two sides of me up, and the idea of approaching anyone I actually know with my own manuscript makes me curl up. No-one I work with had any idea that I was writing. Well… now they do, of course...
- One editor friend I had screwed up courage to talk to about agents gave me some names I should consider. I ended up querying only one of her suggestions, and it’s not the one who took me on.
- I cold queried my agent. I sent my query off to him as a total stranger. I didn’t know any of his clients, nor did I know anyone at his agency. I found him during my own research and he made my top 5 choices. In my very brief bio, I mentioned that I worked in publishing – I didn’t name the company. I haven’t got a clue whether this made him notice my query more than he would have. You’d have to ask him :)
I spent a year getting Fearsome Dreamer to a state where I really thought it was ready to go. I have an agent and an editor. And the manuscript still isn’t ready.
A year from writing those first words to several giant and hundreds of small revisions later, all of which I had done on my own, trying to spot my own mistakes. Mistakes that I had glossed over several times before. Plot holes that didn’t occur to me until months after coming up with the original idea. A point where, in the midst of revisions from my agent, and sick to death of reading my own words for the millionth time, I decided the best way to make myself feel better was to go on twitter and announce to everyone that my book was a boring piece of shit.
My editor will give me more revisions to make. I will probably be working on the book for several months yet.
Call me crazy – but this fills me with an incredible amount of excitement.
There will definitely be more ‘this is a boring piece of shit’ times. I’m an emotional person, and as anyone has ever known me would probably attest, I like to express them. Really, it’s part of the fun of having them. But there will also be, as there was with my agent’s suggestions, 'ohmygod why did I not SEE that thankyousomuchthat’sareallygoodidea' times. And really, the idea that someone loves your made up world enough to want to spend a significant amount of their time in it, making it even better, is a shockingly, gratifyingly nice one.
Good luck to everyone chasing the writing dream.




